The NFL is a quarterback-driven league, and few players have captivated fans like Josh Allen. With a rocket arm, powerful runs, and fearless play, Allen has led the Buffalo Bills to multiple playoff appearances. Yet, despite all the promise, one name still casts a long shadow: Patrick Mahomes. The Kansas City Chiefs continue to dominate the AFC, hoisting Lombardi Trophies while the Bills are left asking what went wrong. The question on every fan’s mind is simple but urgent: what do Josh Allen and the Bills need to do to catch Mahomes and the Chiefs before their Super Bowl window closes?

Year after year, Buffalo starts strong. The regular season often showcases Allen’s brilliance. But when the lights shine brightest, something falters. Painful memories — like the gut-wrenching “13 seconds” game — highlight deeper issues beyond just bad luck. Situational management, defensive execution, and overall team resilience have too often fallen short. And in a conference where Mahomes raises the standard every season, falling just short isn’t good enough anymore.

Josh Allen may possess one of the most complete skill sets in the league, but Mahomes has something Buffalo hasn’t consistently provided: structure. Andy Reid’s offensive system gives Mahomes stability. The Chiefs protect him with a well-coached offensive line, and they surround him with weapons that adapt and perform under pressure. Meanwhile, Allen is often forced to play hero ball, improvising behind a line that struggles and relying on a top target who may not be happy for long.

That brings us to Stefon Diggs. Once considered the missing piece of the Bills’ offense, Diggs has recently been at the center of speculation. Offseason rumors, on-field frustrations, and cryptic posts have sparked concerns about the relationship between Buffalo’s star receiver and its franchise quarterback. If that chemistry deteriorates — or if the front office fails to keep Diggs motivated and engaged — Allen’s already steep climb becomes even steeper. For Buffalo to catch Mahomes and the Chiefs, harmony within the locker room isn’t a luxury; it’s a requirement.

Depth has also been an issue for Buffalo’s offense. Beyond Diggs, there’s a noticeable drop-off in consistent production. Gabe Davis, while capable of explosive plays, has yet to prove himself as a reliable second option week after week. The Bills’ run game still lacks a clear identity, and tight ends remain underutilized despite their potential. When you look at the Chiefs, Mahomes doesn’t always need stars to succeed — he needs options. Kansas City thrives on spreading the ball, using misdirection, and trusting role players to make crucial plays. The Bills must develop a similar philosophy if they hope to compete on the same level.

Defense, too, has been a deciding factor. While the Bills boast a respectable unit during the regular season, they’ve often crumbled when it matters most. Injuries to key veterans like Von Miller have exposed depth issues, and the lack of game-changing plays — especially against elite quarterbacks — has cost them dearly. Mahomes, even when pressured, finds ways to win. Buffalo, by contrast, has struggled to generate momentum-shifting turnovers or key stops. That must change. A defense built for the playoffs — fast, physical, and opportunistic — is essential.

So what do Josh Allen and the Bills need to do to catch Mahomes and the Chiefs? First, they must protect Allen at all costs. That starts with investing in a durable, top-tier offensive line that gives him time to read, react, or run. They also need to diversify the offense. That means creative play-calling, better use of motion and tempo, and giving Allen multiple reliable targets beyond just Diggs. Off the field, the organization must reinforce team chemistry, keep their stars happy, and create an environment where trust fuels performance.

On defense, the Bills can’t settle. They need more speed in the secondary, more aggression up front, and a mindset shift — from preventing big plays to creating game-defining ones. They must study how the Chiefs adapt, reload, and stay ahead. It’s not just about matching Mahomes’ talent — it’s about mirroring their urgency and evolution.

Time is not on Buffalo’s side. Josh Allen is in his prime. The AFC is loaded with hungry teams and rising stars. Meanwhile, Mahomes shows no signs of slowing down. If the Bills hesitate — if they fail to evolve — they won’t just miss their shot at the Chiefs. They might miss their era entirely.